Is Now a Good Time for Active Fund Management?

 
One of the questions investors regularly ask is: “Is now a good time to be more active?”
It usually comes when markets feel uncertain. Perhaps valuations look stretched. There is a war, an election, inflation is causing concern, or some companies are doing extraordinarily well while others are struggling.
The argument sounds perfectly reasonable: surely, when markets are behaving like this, a good fund manager should be able to sort the winners from the losers?
Unfortunately, the evidence suggests it isn’t quite that simple.

Investment professionals sometimes talk about dispersion. This simply describes the difference between the returns of individual companies. When dispersion is high, some shares are performing extremely well while others are doing badly.

In theory, that ought to create a wonderful environment for a skilled stock picker. There are more winners to find and more losers to avoid.

But having more opportunities is only useful if you can reliably identify them in advance.

Research looking at US equity funds between 2006 and 2025 compared the performance of active managers during periods of high and low stock-market dispersion.

The conclusion was interesting. There was little evidence that active managers found it easier to outperform when dispersion was high. In fact, collectively, active funds still underperformed their benchmarks.

That shouldn’t really surprise us.

There are thousands of intelligent analysts and professional investors constantly examining companies, industries and economies.

If a business has fantastic prospects, you probably aren’t the only person who has noticed. Those expectations are usually already reflected, to some degree, in its share price.

This is one of the most important lessons in investing.

The question isn’t simply whether a company will grow.

The question is whether it will perform better than the market already expects.

And consistently identifying those companies before everybody else is extraordinarily difficult.

This doesn’t mean investors should blindly follow an index regardless of price or circumstance.

There is an important distinction between active stock picking and having a flexible investment process. When markets become volatile, trading costs can rise and liquidity can fall.

An index fund may still be required to buy or sell particular companies because an index is changing. A more flexible investment approach can sometimes choose when and how to trade rather than being forced to transact on a particular day.

That might sound like a small distinction, but over decades, seemingly small improvements in implementation and costs can matter.

We don’t believe successful investing requires us to predict the next winning share, the next election, the next recession or where the FTSE 100 will finish next year. Instead, we believe in building broadly diversified portfolios, keeping costs under control, taking sensible and evidence-based risks and allowing markets to do the heavy lifting over time.

There is something very human about wanting to do something when markets become uncomfortable. When prices fall, changing the portfolio can feel reassuring.

But activity isn’t the same as progress. Often the greatest value of good financial planning comes from helping investors avoid decisions they may later regret.

For a long-term investor, the better questions are usually:

If the answer to those questions is YES, predicting whether this is the perfect moment for active management becomes much less important.

I have always believed that good investing should be relatively boring. Your life shouldn’t be.

The purpose of investing isn’t to give you something exciting to talk about. It is to help fund the life you want to live.

Markets will continue to surprise us. There will be periods of exuberance, fear, volatility and uncertainty. There will always be another reason why this time is different.

Rather than trying to outguess millions of other investors, I’d rather concentrate on the things we can control: diversification, costs, tax, behaviour, discipline and having a proper financial plan.

Because ultimately, successful investing isn’t about predicting what happens next. It’s about having a plan that doesn’t depend on you being able to.

Warren Shute CFP®
Chartered Financial Planner
Lexington Wealth Management